par Blockx, Frederic
Référence The Routledge Handbook of EU Copyright Law, Taylor and Francis, page (486-527)
Publication Publié, 2021-01
Partie d'ouvrage collectif
Résumé : This chapter discusses the use of interpretive techniques by the US Supreme Court and by the European Court of Justice in copyright cases. The method of systematic content analysis is used to code the entire body of these cases for the use of any of ten interpretive techniques (or topoi) as identifed by MacCormick, Summers and Tarufo. The introductory part discusses the methods used, followed by a brief overview of the particularities of both courts as all readers are not necessarily equally familiar with the workings of both courts. The frst part consists of a descriptive overview of both case law corpuses. In the second part, the rationale behind copyright law in both systems are discussed. The third and main part of the analysis consists of a presentation and discussion of the statistical analysis performed on the coding of the cases. It will be shown that both courts use six of the ten interpretive techniques similarly, and four diferently: the main diferences are to be found in the interpretation techniques that go back to the legislator’s intent. This leads to the conclusion that the interpretation techniques used by both courts ft the underlying, philosophical and thus substantive diferences in both systems of copyright law. This insight can contribute to a better mutual understanding of the respective systems across both sides of the Atlantic.