Travail de recherche/Working paper
| Résumé : | In the commented judgement (C-432/22), the Court of Justice has ruled on two preliminary questions referred by the Specialised Criminal Court of Bulgaria regarding the interpretation of Bulgarian criminal procedural law in light of EU law, in particular the second subparagraph of Article 19(1) TEU. In this Op-Ed, we argue that the judgement rendered by the Third Chamber of the Court constitutes an important contribution in two main respects. First, it delineates the scope of the EU Charter in the field of (substantive and procedural) criminal law. Second, it further specifies the meaning of the second paragraph of Article 19(1) TEU, by making it a source of the right to a fair trial as part of the right to effective judicial protection. This interpretation is a novelty in the Court’s case law, as arguably for the first time the rights of the defence are applied only on the basis of the Treaties, in a case where the applicability for the Charter is ruled out. |




