par De Brabanter, Philippe 
;Leclercq, Bruno
Référence Topoi, 42, 4, page (1039-1050)
Publication Publié, 2023-09-01
;Leclercq, BrunoRéférence Topoi, 42, 4, page (1039-1050)
Publication Publié, 2023-09-01
Article révisé par les pairs
| Résumé : | We argue for an intimate relation between semantic externalism and semantic deference and propose a typology of speakers’ metasemantic views as revealed by their deferential attitudes. Building on this typology, we then offer a classification of metasemantic disagreements understood as verbal disputes between speakers who (consciously or unconsciously) hold divergent metasemantic views about the same word. In particular, we distinguish lower-order metasemantic disagreements between speakers who disagree on the exact source of meaning determination for a word yet agree on the kind of deferential attitude this word is liable to, from higher-order metasemantic disagreements between speakers who do not even agree on the suitable kind of deferential attitude. We demonstrate the fruitfulness of our classification through the concrete implications it has for conceptual engineering. |
