par Ganty, Sarah
Référence ICON – International Conference of Public Law (4-6 Juillet 2022)
Publication Non publié, 2022-07-06
Communication à un colloque
Résumé : Rights – whether substantive or procedural – are a mirage for some groups because administrative and practical obstacles turn the Rule of Law into a chimaera. In this paper, I argue for the recognition of a right to the effective access to rights, as a core element of the Rule of Law. Tackling this issue is crucially important. Indeed, if the principle of equality before the law and fundamental rights have been widely recognised as part of the Rule of Law, one conundrum remains: many people do not have access to the rights they are entitled to because of practical and administrative barriers. Some sporadic measures and laws – “traces” of the right to the effective access to rights – have been taken to alleviate these problems, in a limited way however. I argue that beyond the “right to have rights”, as masterfully theorised by Hannah Arendt concerning post-war stateless persons, the Fundamental rights become an empty promise and the Rule of Law is not worthy of its name if they do not encompass a general right to the effective access to rights deriving from substantive and procedural rights. In short, the right to have effective access to rights is not a pleonasm.