Contribution to the research on drug resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis

First of all, a profound analysis of the MDR-TB situation in Belgium was conducted. It is the first retrospective population-based survey of MDR-TB in Belgium, covering a 15-year period (1994-2008). It comprises 174 patients representing more than 80% of the culture positive MDR-TB patients reported to the Belgian register, thus this study is considered of national relevance. It includes bacteriological and molecular data on the isolates as well as clinical aspects of the patients and treatment results. Considering only the patient’s first MDR-TB isolate, an increase over time was observed in the number of isolates resistant to a second-line drug as well as the total number of drugs each isolate was resistant to. XDR-TB was detected since 2002 and panresistant TB (resistant to every available antituberculosis drug) since 2009. Overall, a successful treatment outcome was obtained for 67.8% of the MDR-TB cases. Drug susceptibility testing (DST) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis to first line drugs (isoniazid, rifampicin, ethambutol and pyrazinamide) in liquid culture medium has a turn around time of at least two weeks, after identification of the positive culture (obtained after 2 to 4 weeks) from the patient’s clinical isolate. In order to provide the clinician with valuable information about the isolated mycobacteria leading to patient adapted therapy before bacteriological DST results are available, resistance is predicted by detection of mutations in certain genes of the mycobacteria. It is common practice for rifampicin (rpoB gene) and isoniazid (katG gene and/or inhA promoter region). In this MDR-TB collection, rifampicin resistant related mutations were found in 97.1% (168/173) of the clinical isolates and isoniazid resistant related mutations in 94.1% (160/170). The pncA, embB and gyrA genes have been sequenced to identify possible mutations because of their possible involvement with resistance to pyrazinamide, ethambutol and the fluoroquinolones respectively. However, little is known about the resistance prediction value of the mutations in these genes.

The study is also the first study on the molecular epidemiology of MDR-TB in the country. DNA fingerprinting showed a large diversity of strains (67% of the patients were infected by a strain with a unique pattern) and further epidemiological examination revealed limited local transmission of MDR-TB in Belgium.

The second part investigated the pncA gene and its association with pyrazinamide resistance in MDR-TB isolates from Belgium and in vitro cultured spontaneous mutants. The genetic analysis showed that 98.3% (59/60) of the Belgian clinical MDR pyrazinamide resistant (PZAR) isolates present a mutation in the pncA gene. We found 1.7% (1/60) of the PZAR MDR-isolates encoding wild type pncA and flank. A total (PZAR and PZAS) of 41 different amino acid changes, 3 protein truncations and 5 frameshifts were observed including eight novel mutations: 8Asp>Ala, 13Phe>Leu, 64Tyr>Ser, 107Glu>stop, 143Ala>Pro, 172Leu>Arg and frameshifts starting in codon 55 and 82. Analysis of all observed mutations (i.e. in clinical isolates as well as spontaneous mutants) revealed that they are not always associated with drug resistance and that they are not scattered randomly throughout the gene, but occur rather at preferential sites such as in codons with amino acids associated with either iron or substrate binding and catalytic active sites. The frequency of in vitro mutagenesis to pyrazinamide at pH 6.0 was determined and found to be relatively high at 10-5 CFU/ml.

Finally, the in vitro activity of tobramycin and clarithromycin (with unclear efficacy against M. tuberculosis) was evaluated on 25 M. tuberculosis clinical isolates with various resistance profiles. The effect of the drugs administered together was examined for possible synergistic effect. The median minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of 8 µg/ml obtained for both drugs in this study is rather high but are beyond the concentrations obtained in lung tissues. This suggests that both drugs should be investigated further as potential adjuncts to the treatment of resistant TB when other alternatives have failed; in particularly through new drug delivery systems such as the Dry Power Inhaler which allows local drug deposition with high drug concentrations in the lungs but low toxicity due to limited systemic absorption. In addition, for 36% of the tested isolates a decrease of the MIC of clarithromycin by a single or twofold dilution was observed in the presence of a subinhibitory concentration of tobramycin and no antagonistic effect was seen for the remaining isolates.

This research illustrates different (laboratory) aspects in the fight against drug resistant TB, all using the Belgian TB collection: characterisation of the Belgian MDR-TB situation on bacteriological, molecular and epidemiological level; profound analysis of genomic mutations and their possible association with drug resistance; and investigation of synergistic activity of drugs with low efficacy against M. tuberculosis.